San Carlos On The Gulf Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

Welcome to San Carlos On The Gulf, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, Florida. This charming neighborhood offers a delightful blend of coastal living and community spirit, making it an ideal location for families, retirees, and anyone looking to embrace the laid-back Florida lifestyle.

San Carlos On The Gulf boasts a variety of homes that are perfect for those seeking a non-gated community. Here, you’ll find a mix of charming single-family homes and cozy beach cottages, many of which feature stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. With properties designed to enhance the natural beauty of the area, you’ll feel right at home in this picturesque setting.

The neighborhood is characterized by its friendly atmosphere, where neighbors become friends and community events bring everyone together. Enjoy leisurely strolls along the tree-lined streets, or take advantage of the nearby parks and recreational areas perfect for picnics and outdoor activities. The proximity to the beach means that sun-soaked days and breathtaking sunsets are just moments away.

San Carlos On The Gulf is also conveniently located near a variety of shops, restaurants, and entertainment options, ensuring that everything you need is within easy reach. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, unique boutiques, or vibrant nightlife, Fort Myers Beach has it all.

If you’re looking for a welcoming community with a relaxed vibe and beautiful homes, San Carlos On The Gulf is the perfect place to call home. Experience the best of Florida living in this charming neighborhood where every day feels like a vacation!

Newest San Carlos On The Gulf Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

$1,999,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026008594 MLS

Coming 2026, White Sands and Sea Glass are elevated coastal residences in the prestigious San Carlos on the Gulf neighborhood of Fort Myers Beach, positioned among luxury homes and removed from the congestion of the main beach district. Featuring expansive open-concept living, oversized rooms, and refined coastal finishes, the elevated main level captures natural light and enhanced views. Built to current hurricane standards with elevator rough-in and optional pool, this is sophisticated island living offering comfort, privacy, and long-term coastal value, all within walking distance to beaches, marina’s, and waterfront dining. Pre-construction opportunity; pricing may evolve as construction progresses.

961 San Carlos CT, Fort Myers Beach

$3,399,000

226001800 MLS

Commanding an extraordinary half-acre of bayfront along the rising shores of San Carlos Island, this is the kind of opportunity that rarely surfaces—and never lasts. Encompassing an impressive 20,830 square feet with 100 feet of direct bay frontage and an exceptional depth of approximately 215 feet, this premier homesite delivers a level of scale, presence, and design freedom that is virtually unmatched across Southwest Florida. Positioned with coveted western exposure, the property is perfectly oriented to capture breathtaking sunset views over wide-open water, while a deep-water canal alongside provides quick, unobstructed access to the Gulf of Mexico—an ideal combination for both boating enthusiasts and those seeking a true waterfront lifestyle. A newer dock is already in place, thoughtfully designed to accommodate two boat lifts, allowing you to begin enjoying the water from day one while planning your custom coastal estate. The size and configuration of this parcel offer endless possibilities for expansive indoor-outdoor living, resort-style amenities, and a truly architectural statement home. San Carlos Island is quickly emerging as one of Southwest Florida’s most exciting luxury destinations, attracting discerning homeowners, investors, and top-tier builders. The location strikes a rare balance—just a short stroll to Fort Myers Beach’s iconic waterfront dining, and moments from the vibrant energy of Margaritaville Resort and the area’s world-renowned beaches—yet uniquely positioned to avoid the congestion typically associated with island living. With seamless access to Sanibel, Captiva, Bonita Springs, Naples, and RSW International Airport, convenience is unmatched. Whether you envision a private bayfront estate or a high-performing luxury rental—enhanced by the area’s no rental restrictions—this offering represents a compelling blend of lifestyle and investment potential. Half an acre of prime bayfront, deep-water Gulf access, sweeping sunset views, and exceptional proximity to Fort Myers Beach—948 San Carlos Boulevard is more than a homesite; it’s a rare canvas to create something truly remarkable.

948 San Carlos DR, Fort Myers Beach

$4,200,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 2026002641 MLS

This is the Fort Myers Beach property that truly has it all—bayfront luxury with Gulf views, oversized grounds, income potential, and resort-style amenities. With 7 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and an elevator, this exceptional estate is designed for both comfort and convenience, offered fully turnkey. The main residence rises three levels above a private apartment that opens directly to the heated pool and jacuzzi. Multiple balconies and screened decks capture long water views, while the top-level bedroom lookout provides a panoramic perspective of both Estero Bay and the Gulf of America. A wood-burning fireplace adds warmth and character to the spacious living areas. A separate guest house with its own garage sits at the front of the property and is currently leased to a long-term tenant, delivering a proven consistent annual rental income. The main home also offers excellent rental income, making this both a lifestyle retreat and a smart investment. Boaters will appreciate the private dock, complete with a captain’s walk and a 10,000 lb. boat lift—ideal for quick access to open water. The oversized lot enhances the estate feel, providing rare space and privacy on Fort Myers Beach. Perfectly located to avoid the heavy beach traffic yet just minutes from the shoreline, dining, and entertainment, this property offers the best of island living. With unmatched views, exceptional amenities, and turnkey convenience, this is one of the most remarkable opportunities on Fort Myers Beach.

950 San Carlos DR, Fort Myers Beach

$675,000

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2025025290 MLS

Perfect Investment Opportunity on beautiful San Carlos Island. Property is surrounded by multi million dollar homes on the Bay. Long Term tenants are currently occupying the building. This is a great location with walking distance less than 10 minutes over the bridge to Fort Myers Beach. A new traffic light has been installed at the base of the Beach to make cross over safe. Each unit has its own ground level entry accessible from either the garage or outside. Plenty of storage space and parking area in the oversized garage. New air conditioning system installed after Ian and there was no damage to the raised units. Both units have been remodeled within the last five years and are in great condition. There is an additional unfinished 2 bedroom one bath unit in the rear at ground level for additional rental potential. unit San Carlos Island offers many amenities such as restaurants, Dixie Fish, Doc Fords And the new Fish house within short walking distance. Many great projects are planned for the future.

842 South ST, Fort Myers Beach

$5,485,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6.5 Baths ⋅ 225082699 MLS

This is 793 San Carlos Drive—less a house and more a waypoint on the map of a life well-lived. A modern coastal refuge tucked into the salty heartbeat of Fort Myers Beach, where the air smells of sunburnt afternoons and the tide keeps its own kind of time. Built the right way—block and steel from the ground all the way up to the roof. Perfectly positioned for those grand, cinematic sunsets that spill across Matanzas Bay, the kind you watch in silence because words just get in the way. Built for poolside barbeques that run late, for Florida winter nights when conversation drifts like smoke, for slow bike rides to seafood joints where the fish are still telling stories from the Gulf. Inside, two primary suites and four guest rooms, all en-suite, make it the sort of place where family converges, friends linger, and nobody feels like they drew the short straw. It’s a home that doesn’t just host memories; it cooks them slowly, like something that gets better the longer you let it simmer. The kitchen is the soul of it all. Mid-century esque meets modern, a space begging for simple ingredients, good knives, and better company. From here, you can watch the world wander by on the water while you stir, chop, taste, and exist—exactly as you are. From the terrace, the view opens in soft, deliberate layers—first across untouched Grayson Island and its protected bird sanctuary, then out toward the distant shimmer of Fort Myers Beach’s skyline, with the Sanibel Causeway stretching quietly along the eastern edge of the horizon. Up top, the dual primary suites hide away like little sanctuaries, each with wide-open views that remind you why people chase the horizon in the first place. Everything inside has been curated with a sharp, contemporary eye—furnishings that feel effortless, textures that feel intentional. It’s the kind of place you can step into and immediately exhale. Turn the key, and you’re already living the life. With Control4 automation, hidden surround sound, a Tesla charger, Generac generator and a build engineered to shrug off coastal moods, this home blends luxury with durability. A place made for people who appreciate beauty—but also know that the world is imperfect, unpredictable, and worth experiencing anyway. The water keeps its rhythm. The sunsets write their own script. All that’s missing is someone to call it home. Perhaps that’s you. Schedule a showing today.

793 San Carlos DR, Fort Myers Beach

$2,099,000

225070838 MLS

Bayfront Bliss Meets Coastal Adventure – 60 Feet of Waterfront Views - A Lot Like No Other! Unmatched opportunity awaits with this extraordinary Bayfront/Gulf-access property on San Carlos Island. Offering 60 Feet of Panoramic Waterfront Views and effortless access to the Gulf with no-bridge boating in just five minutes. This rare lot provides a pristine canvas for crafting a spectacular single-family estate or an impressive duplex that celebrates Southwest Florida’s coastal lifestyle. The adjacent parcel (926) MLS #225070841 is also available if you desire a larger footprint or wish to create an expansive dream estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Savor breathtaking sunsets and watch a lively parade of boats from your own backyard, or head out to some of the region’s best fishing grounds. With dozens of waterfront restaurants just a short boat ride away, every outing becomes an adventure. Perfectly positioned within walking distance of the sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet tucked away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined permitting and building process. Opportunities of this caliber are exceptionally rare, offering the freedom to design a home that captures the very best of bayfront living and the relaxed, vibrant spirit of Southwest Florida.

922 San Carlos DR, Fort Myers Beach

$1,999,000

225070841 MLS

60 Feet of Waterfront Views – A Bayfront Jewel on San Carlos Island! Waterfront royalty awaits on this rare, 60-foot stretch of bayfront paradise—perfectly positioned with no-bridge boating to the Gulf in just five minutes. This extraordinary property offers a blank canvas for creating a single-family estate or even a stunning duplex worthy of its setting. An optional adjacent parcel (922) MLS #225070838 is also available if you desire a larger estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Spend your days boating to a dozen nearby restaurants for lunch or dinner, or simply savor serene sunsets over the bay from your own backyard. Located a short stroll from the pristine, sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined building process. Rarely do opportunities of this caliber present themselves. Here, you can design and build a residence that captures the very best of bayfront living, offering privacy, beauty, and the quintessential Southwest Florida lifestyle.

926 San Carlos DR, Fort Myers Beach

$569,000

225022280 MLS

Location, location, location . . . this well-priced commercial parcel is located off San Carlos Drive just this side of the bridge It's within walking or biking distance from our beautiful sandy beaches, and surrounded by fine dining like Doc Ford's and Dixie Fish House. Property is zoned C-1. Located behind Diversified Yacht Services with million dollar homes across the street on the Bay.

752 San Carlos DR, Fort Myers Beach

$524,900

223019019 MLS

These motivated Seller’s just reduced the price over 50K! Now is your opportunity to build your dream home on this prime, Ft. Myers Beach Lot. Enjoy a bike ride, stroll or take your golf cart to local restaurants and shops, while catching the breathtaking sunsets of San Carlos Island. This lot is completely cleared and ready to build. Come and be a part of the revitalization of the vibrant island community of Fort Myers Beach. You have found your very own 'Peace' of Paradise!

947 San Carlos DR, Fort Myers Beach

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.